ReadWriteWeb quotes Karim, one of its own commenters, who was responding to a pro-Google Docs piece on the site a few days ago. Setting aside the fact that the public barely knows about online office suites in general, there are just too damn many great quotes in here about the significant functionality problems that plague Web 2.0 apps, such as:
Open a Google doc. Paste an image. Oh, that’s right, you can’t Ctrl-C copy, Ctrl-V PASTE an image into a document. Ok, so INSERT an image. Now proportionally resize the image so it retains its aspect ratio. Oh, that’s right, you can’t. Now crop the image. Oh that’s right, you can’t.
and
Now type some text and select it. Choose one of the fonts on your computer instead of the six fonts Google licensed from Microsoft. Oh wait, you can’t. Create a new paragraph style. Oh wait, you can’t. Change the font color and background on some text. Now copy that formatting to another paragraph. Oh wait, you can’t.
and
People just love to use software where some incredibly basic feature like “search & replace” is marked with “WARNING! EXPERIMENTAL! Use eye protection! This could blow up in your face!”
and
Finally you tell us that “Google will win this battle” is because “they have the economic engine,” meaning, they have advertising in all their stuff. Yay capitalism. I know the last six times I used a word processor, I kept thinking it needed more advertising.
I know I quoted about half the entire comment, but head over and read the rest; it’s all good stuff. Karim’s right: Google Docs and similar offerings can certainly do the trick for people who need some of the absolute basic office features. But they consistently fall short when you get to the rest of the basic features, never mind anything even marginally more powerful that most of the real world uses.
Considering all this, and being the fan of desktop software’s power and integration, I see a lot more potential in services like Microsoft’s new private beta Office Live Workspace which I wrote about for Ars back in December. It’s more of an online conduit for sharing files and offline collaboration; there’s no web-based editing right now, though limited features are on their way. Never mind the fact that Office is one of Microsoft’s largest revenue generating products‚ÄîOffice Live Workspace provides an easy way for home and small business users to share and collaborate on documents, yet still harness the vast power of the desktop Office suite.
Sure, some day we’ll all have flying cars, ubiquitous, terabyte Internet connections, and web apps with all sorts of super powers. Until then, and web apps for making lists of things to get done notwithstanding, desktop software is where the real power for getting things done lies.